The Nineteenth Amendment and the Clancy Trail
Are We Still Thinking Critically?
By: Alexandra Verrigni
The Lindsey Clancy trial has caught the attention of the entire public eye. A mass controversy over the culpability of Lindsey’s crime has caused almost everyone to voice their opinion on the case. It seems clear to the majority that Lindsey is responsible for the murders of her three children. Whether the murders can be excused by clinical insanity or not seems to be the matter which is up in the air. There is a difference of opinion on what sort of punishment she should face because of this disagreement.
As a psychology major, it seems deeply questionable to me, and many others, that a woman was permitted to, and prescribed, some twelve different medications within the span of three months. The case seemed to barely scrape the surface concerning the timeline of these prescriptions and their medical implications, both in relation to Clancy’s mental health, and the ethics of the medical field. It is safe to say that the psychiatrists, psychologists, and doctors involved in Clancy’s case should be further investigated, as well as the psychiatric field as a whole.
Despite this medical ambiguity and possible negligence, it is still overwhelmingly clear that Lindsey did not commit the murders of her three children strictly because of postpartum psychosis. Psychiatrists working in the case testified that Lindsey was not suffering from acute postpartum psychosis (nor depression, which would never justify murder on the basis of insanity as psychosis potentially could). Rather, when she killed her children, Clancy’s stated excuse was that she did not want her children to “suffer” after she attempted to kill herself.
Infanticide, Abortion, and the Nineteenth Amendment
Aside from these nuances, the case has raised alarming concerns about the cultural state of Americans regarding their opinions on the sanctity of life and women’s rights. Some Americans have expressed support or even sympathy for Lindsey, causing large debates online. Although infanticide is the logical step which follows from the ideology of pro-choicers, certain voices on the right have suddenly raised the case as contention for women to lose their voting rights because of Lindsey Clancy supporters. For example, Jeannie DeAngelis recently advocated for the disenfranchisement of women’s voting rights in an American Spectator article.

Women’s Rights Protest
Considering that the majority of Americans (60%) believe that abortion should be legal, it may not be shocking that some Americans justify infanticide. However, it would be incredibly insulting to all of the victims of abortion to compare a rare case of infanticide to the countless cases of abortion.
It is true that no murderers should have the right to vote. It is odd that the issue seems to have spiked interest when abortion is already a widespread and common issue for political discourse when it comes to the Nineteenth Amendment. I strongly insist that there is a huge danger in following and applying such a simplistic line of reasoning to the entire female population. This reductive argument is a hazardous for numerous reasons; it utilizes progressive feminist logic, presumes the implementation of a case law made based on the trial, diminishes the ongoing issue of abortion, omits the ongoing bigger picture of the psychological operation of gender wars, disregards similar cases pertaining to men, and endorses the loss of a constitutional right for over half of the American population.
Rare Illness, False Premises
Critics of the Nineteenth Amendment argue that: “if women are so emotionally unstable that they can’t be blamed for killing their own children, then why should they be entitled to the same rights and responsibilities as men?” In other words, if hormones prevent women from controlling their actions, why should society grant them the right to vote? Unfortunately, this logic assumes so many false premises about women. Maybe most glaringly obvious, the idea that all women will have children, and following this, the idea that all women who have children will suffer from postpartum psychosis. Postpartum psychosis, different from postpartum depression, is rare, affecting only 1 per 1,000 mothers. Of those 1 in 1,000, only 4% of these women diagnosed with postpartum psychosis actually kill their children. Combine the decreasing birth rate with the rarity of postpartum psychosis and this argument only begins to unravel.
Why Clancy Cannot Become Case Law
In order for it to actually be legally feasible for a woman to get away with murdering her children because of postpartum psychosis, the creation of a new case law would be necessary. This theoretical case law would have to justify infanticide through something other than postpartum psychosis. We know Clancy was not suffering psychosis at the time when she killed her children. So far, Clancy’s trial has ended in a mistrial. The evidence already establishes that she was not suffering from postpartum psychosis during the killings.

An Empty Courtroom
For example, courts rarely accept the Andrea Yates case as a standard defense for infanticide when a mother receives a postpartum psychosis diagnosis. Yates’s case would not even apply to Clancy. She was not suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed her children. Furthermore, courts interpret and apply precedents according to the circumstances of each individual case. “Congress intentionally leaves the law undefined to allow for flexible, case-by-case application of the law,” making it even harder for one to be created in this scenario. The argument that Clancy’s case would wholly justify the majority of infanticide cases –and therefore wholly invalidate the Nineteenth Amendment– is beyond unrealistic.
A Slippery Slope Conservatives Should Reject
Aside from the lack of evidence that the majority of women would find themselves in such a unique predicament, the argument against women’s voting, especially from conservatives, is wildly tone-deaf. Modern culture increasingly encourages people to degrade the opposite gender. If we feed into it, we have already lost the vital Christian values that helped shape this nation. One would expect conservatives, who are overwhelmingly Christians (82%) would value the voting rights of both men and women equally. Women only gained the right to vote in the United States in 1920, after fighting for over 100 years, where faith played a fundamental role. Because men in their society failed to represent their interests, women fought for the same God-given right to vote as men.
Women outnumber men in the American population and among registered voters. There are more registered Democrats than Republicans. Apart from Independents, which make up 45% of registered voters, subsequently, the majority of partisan voters are liberal women. This does not mean they should simply lose the right that all women fought so hard for. Other groups, including non-white Americans, also fought for hundreds of years to secure proper representation. Perhaps those who advocate revoking women’s voting rights would also deny representation to other marginalized groups. This is a slippery slope which begs the question; how far are they willing to go?
Men Commit Most of the Violence
I could easily make a much stronger argument to revoke the voting rights of men. They commit far more murder, rape, crime, and are way more likely to kill not only their children, but their entire family. Men make up 80% of the United States violent crime rate. They account for 88-90% of murder and homicide. In addition, men make up 99% of pregnancy homicides, with 45% being the father of the child. When it comes to killing entire families, men are overwhelmingly more likely to, making up 90-95% of familicides.
I find an argument to revoke the voting rights of men far more compelling than the argument presented against women because of the Clancy Case. However, I do not propose to revoke the voting rights of all men. When someone proposes the repeal of basic constitutional rights, it is fair to assume that they might not stop at just women. It is a founding principle of America that its citizens may represent themselves. If we shift these principles, the ideas that founded our nation disappear.
Gender Wars and the Meaning of Conservatism
Finally, media outlets pushed this case during a time of growing gender division in American culture. Psychological operations often include basic elements such as planning and timelines, targeted audiences, and immersion with other viewers’ belief systems. They also rely on subtle communication through social media, news, and books. Over time, the operation is implemented so inconspicuously that it seems to be the natural outcome of the culmination of a set of previously accepted set of beliefs. The media appears to have used this relatively small case to further the gender divide. This seems to be one of the reasons the case is causing far right men to advocate for revoking women’s voting rights.

Social Media Apps
Sometimes it seems to me that those on the far right have lost an understanding of conservatism and what it means to have conservative values. Conservatism is inherently a Christian political ideology. Yet so-called conservatives increasingly endorse ideas that contradict Christian principles. The values of the nation include inalienable rights such as freedom of speech, the right to life, and the right to representation. It is quite ironic that these same values, which allow the American people to express their opinions on such matters, are the ones under attack by certain ‘conservatives.’ Perhaps it may be a good thing that those who are incapable of deeply investigating their reductive reasoning are so willingly compliant to give up their right to vote so quickly. However, if their reasoning capabilities are flawed, they should not be quick to advocate for the disenfranchisement of others.
About the Author
Alexandra Verrigni is a junior marketing fellow at the Institute for Faith and Freedom at Grove City College. She is majoring in psychology and minoring in philosophy. With an interest in politics, she hopes to pursue public and family policy research in the future. This past semester, she has helped her psychology professor, Dr. Lucian Conway, conduct research on the Authoritarianism Tracker Project. She has experience both helping to found and working as the secretary of the Grove City College Republicans. Alexandra has worked with Susan B. Anthony Pro-life America as both a canvasser, door-knocking in key swing states and counties, and as a campus recruiter, encouraging students to sign up for canvassing deployments. She has also been involved in the Young Women for America and Life Advocates clubs on campus.
READ MORE CULTURE: Family Without Responsibility Is No Family at All.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed are those of the writer alone and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of Grove City College, the Institute for Faith and Freedom, or their affiliates.
Cover Image: Wikimedia Commons (Public Domain)
Captioned Image 1: Photo by Gayatri Malhotra on Unsplash (Cropped)
Captioned Image 2: Photo by David Veksler on Unsplash (Cropped)
Captioned Image 3: Photo by Berke Citak on Unsplash (Cropped)
